So, this might be a bit old (Easter, obs), but I found these pics and just had to show you how creative (read: dorky) my husband is. He'll be such a good dad!
The egg on the right is a crossword puzzle. The egg on the left is a ninja.
The finger puppet is one of Ellen's toys. Mike hijacked it.
Now that you know the cast, I'm sure you can figure out the rest.
Gotta love his creativity and enthusiasm for the arts :)